Lost and Foundry

velcrosasquatch

New member
Jul 24, 2023
2
2
3
velcrosasquatch submitted a new resource:

Lost and Foundry - Techbase/dieselpunk themed map for Arcane Dimensions.

Take a trip to a place thought long lost...
Lost and Foundry is made out of my strong desire to make an Arcane Dimensions map and features. It features around 90 enemies and should only take 5-15 minutes to beat. I really wanted to understand the privatives that make up a typical map and be able to re-create them and make use of them multiple times properly in a way that didn't feel 'rehashy'. While Lost and Foundry isn't my first Quake map thanks to the Reload Jam, it was my first idea that...

Read more about this resource...
 
I never do this, but I'm doing it now. This is a review based off another anonymous review, which is why it's here and not on the front page.

Setup. I am mind numbingly consistent when it comes to reviews:

- I don't review blind nightmare, I do blind normal and go back on nightmare if I'm chomping for more. I stopped doing blind nightmare after I found several releases I greatly enjoyed that were either very blind hostile on nightmare or were just way more fun on a lower skill (rubicon2 stuff falls heavily in the second category from all the hitscanners). Missing good releases because blind nightmare isn't fun is dumb.

- I despise significant ammo restriction. Not that I shouldn't ever run out of ammo, but if I'm constantly axing things on a blind normal play through I'll just dump out mid map. There is zero issue here with that here.

- I'm not a mapper. Things only mappers will notice I don't care about.

- Puns, jokes, good writing, including a demo, music, stuff I would put in the "polish" category I love. Your set pieces and jokes are fun and were called out somewhere which was why I played the map at all, keep doing this.

- I give bonus points for Arcane Dimensions because I greatly prefer Arcane Dimensions over copper, alkaline, quoth, etc.

- Any time I say, "never do this," it's really, "never do this unless you're sure, and please ignore my self imposed Quake rules if it makes your release better, even if it doesn't make it better for me (some random asshole on the internet) because I recognize not all releases are targeted at me and that's FINE." I'm a big boy and prefectly fine with someone taking a criticism from me and discarding it because it doesn't fit their vision.

I went back and replayed release 1 on nightmare. On my replay I died exactly twice, both times to my own bad target prioritization on the boss. I completed the map in 13:23 with 4/5 secrets and the following resources:

1708276066939.png


From the anonymous review:

- "Map is not sealed," I don't approve of criticizing minor tech issues, especially if it can be trivially fixed with one update release. The call out is fine, getting called out when I miss something is how I learn. "It's one of those things where if you don't know what vis is, you just shouldn't be releasing the map," is a shit take however. The only vis issue I noticed on my second run relates to exactly one secret.

- The ladder thing I noticed, but didn't call out because Quake ladders suck. They're inconsistently either "hold jump" to climb or "walk forward" to climb and you never know which it's going to be. I think I prefer walk forward, but if this is tied to AD I wouldn't make yourself crazy over it. I never call it out unless it has a major negative effect on an encounter. While it's an elevator and not a ladder, there's an encounter in Blood that illustrates a great example of, "Abusing the player's awkward up and down movement is dickish,"
Great example of up and down movement being used in a blind unfriendly way that I wouldn't tolerate. You never did that and if you continue not doing that you'll be fine.

- The grenade resistant enemies I had zero issue with. I never even found the grenade launcher on my first play through (the Half Life bit is funny). I can guess where he ran into the issue (the room right before the super nail gun) but if he had an ammo issue there on blind nightmare I'm indifferent as I'm indifferent to blind nightmare (you can also just run around them and grab the nailgun). They mention saving the grenade launcher ammo for tough encounters, I main it. I've always felt that Quake expects you to main explosives when you have them since the shotguns are weak compared to Doom 2's super shotgun, Blood's shotgun, Unreal's flak cannon, etc.

- Related to that, Quake's enemy roster is fairly limited, even in AD/Alkaline/etc. Never using a particular enemy doesn't help that and mixing up enemy types is generally a good idea, if you want to see tedium caused by fighting the same guy over and over again play the end of the Quake 2 rogue expansion (I never want to see a spongey railgunner again) or Freedoom 1's episode 4. I'm fine with spawns if you don't Sandy Peterson them and despise vores, but I wouldn't tell you to never use vores (I don't think the reviewer is saying that, but just as an example).

- Texturing I didn't notice. Probably because stock textures being used weirdly is kind of on brand for classic Quake.
If you haven't looked at them (they'd be hard to miss) Makkon's textures are always great https://www.slipseer.com/index.php?resources/makkon-textures.28/
The ones in the recent horde map releases are great https://www.slipseer.com/index.php?resources/diesel-cathedral-horde-mode-map-2.319/
And there's some great texture work being done over in doom land you could use like Otex's texture packs https://www.doomworld.com/forum/topic/103426-otex-texture-set-–-update-2020-version-11-released/

- I don't know what they're talking about with size and scope, this map is packed with a bunch of cool little set pieces but isn't actually that big. Certainly not as dense as like Forgotten Sepulcher but not the bland open nothingness of 90% of the QZone maps I unfortunately played. Nothing felt like an over reach.

Having gotten annoyed at what I see as a somewhat flippant 2 from an anonymous reviewer enough to go back and replay the map on nightmare then sit down and write this wall of text, my opinion hasn't changed. It's a somewhat simply constructed but very enjoyable to play map. The set pieces and jokes are funny and appreciated, the fights are okay, and the pacing is good. I think my only new complaint would be the map is ad but isn't named as such (ad_found).

Good show.
 
Last edited: