There are around 70 hours of quite good gameplay here unless you rush through everything without being a little curious as most of these maps are beautifully dense.
I love the new monster behaviours (as well as their looks, animations, sounds, the whole lot). They are generally easy to spot in fights to help you prioritise high stakes targets. Sometimes though I swear they act like silent assassins as not all of them have audible footsteps, to pair with their super speed (at least on Nightmare). Depending on the player location the monsters' movement can also be manipulated, though sometimes it can backfire, it does make fights really dynamic, I both like and dislike this aspect, challenging yet sometimes fun(ny).
The arsenal likewise is awesome, though I never really felt comfortable with the Rebar, I wish more maps tried to experiment by giving it early on as a tool to rely on like in Mazu's Snack Pack 3 map.
Since this is a 70+ map jam I'll have to cram my thoughts on the maps in general and those that stood out to me but this was all around a great pack, every map deserves a try. There are MANY styles, catering to different sensibilities regarding difficulty, interpretations of the visual theme, inclusion of puzzles as part of progression and length (and mapper experience, a lot of the first time maps submissions are really good). It is very handy to keep a notepad to remind yourself which map was what, and if you backed out of it early to remind yourself why.
Main Gallery
The Monument - Most stylish Control style lobby. It is cosy, it is jaw dropping, it is everything.
RadiatorYang - One of the few freeform / sandbox-y style maps, high risk high reward exploration and combat. Visuals are also killer. One of the best.
Spootnik Wasser - Super compact, all killer no filler. Very classic Spootnik style map. We need more bitesized maps like this.
Annihilazor - Great aesthetically, very cosy combat up until the end where it's a bit much. Still fun to go through to appreciate the environment.
h4724 - Compact and super dense. Moody and tricky, very fun. The literal spaces for the arenas are awesome, a lot of room to play around with.
Avix day at the gym - Possibly too much concrete, if you don't stray too far off the beaten path there are some neat encounters here.
Lob - Neat encounters and bite sized. I like the ending area visually a lot.
rabbit - Great visuals, both liminal and action packed. Felt like a fun and eerie grand adventure.
ZetaByt - Very classic ZetaByt style, good use of the new monster types without it feeling like a chore. This map's quiet moments are nice.
Tei - Another pretty bitesized map, one of the few that I wish stuck around a little longer. Good use of simple spaces.
Jan - I actually like the liminality and emptiness that is present at times, it is very pretty and in a probably unintentional way can provide story telling.
DrMelon - Cruel and unusual, it is fun to figure out however.
chadquad - Simple and cosy, the pistol can workhorse a bit through the map but it picks up later.
Chuma - A lot of unique rooms, the neon lights live on.
Sewer - Very brutal, potentially too brutal, the wave based encounters are really cool though. It looks the part too. The accent strip lights are pretty.
Milestone - Super unique shapes for the architecture, good flow even with the possibility of sequence breaks. One of the few maps that dared with cool puzzles and turned out great for it. One of the best.
Shades - Really pretty locale, the qbj3 arsenal kinda ravaged through the map though. The ending is also great. Very Shades map.
PixelDud - Super cool bitesized atmospheric map. I wish one of the zones had a bit more going on but this was cool and weird.
sze - Great flow and looks. It is potentially easy to get lost a little bit despite the signposting if you are secret hunting. Very well done dilapidated environments. Great humour too. One of the best.
Spootnik Materials - Really well done reimagination of 2 vanilla maps. Unlimited Invoker is great and since this is a Spoot map, yes you do need very good footwork. Very cool and great lighting.
Zbidou - Classic Zbidou. huge scale, tricksy combat, adventure game style progression in a very believable space. One of the best despite my hatred of boats.
Pinchy - Was surprised at the lack of a slaughter or crazy start, very much appreciated this slow burner pace. Very atmospheric with very pretty environments. The Shambler zone with the wooden boards is awesome. Didn't even realise the STALKER reference until I heard the geiger counter go off lol. One of the best.
haikids - Even without the lighting pass this map is neat. I'm liking the simple style with Portal and Half Life sensibilities. Just need to care about potential softlocks with elevators.
SimonN - Starts out crazy and doesn't ever really slow down. The textures theme and lighting is great (expect for the zombie area on nightmare lol). I like the 3 main themes going on. The fight where you need to keep on pressing the button is not for me though. The cube hitting mechanic is a little weird as I don't think you can properly backtrack in the map but it is neat. Very unique.
wiedo - Great combat in a bitesized package.
PuLSaR - The scale of this is really cool, very atmospheric and creepy. Perilous combat. Secrets are very fun and some of the best use for the seamless teleports. One of the best.
riktoi - Cool visual style with neat combat. Escape sequence is great.
ThatSpacePirate - Great mood, progression can be a little weird. Lots of great sequences with tricky combat.
Naitelveni - I love the stinkyness of this map, kind of similar to Warpspasm's "Bile Plant". Nice and compact. Backtracking for secrets is a little weird and I assume it will be addressed in an update. Love the bedroom.
FifthElephant - Cosy void map. Most void maps in the pack had a little too much going on so this was a nice change of pace. Visually nice too.
JakubM - With a reduction to scale, not even by a lot this would actually be great. Very homely and silly. Central idea is fun.
EberN150 - Probably the most unique map in the pack. It dared to use the seamless teleports the most and it mostly succeeded in being easy to understand (still tricky), both for general progression and secrets. Combat can be annoying but it's generally fun. The 2-3 themes are pretty too. Can't tell if I prefered the caves or the elevators. One of the best.
vanisch - Visually this is awesome, combat is fun minus the necessary zombie kills. The buttons need to stand out more however. Nice and compact.
Scampie - Really good flow and very distinct arenas. Was a joy to go through.
F15H00K - Very tricksy arenas with a nice colour theme. It was satisfying to overcome.
ROJ - Many small moving parts and places to see, it is dense, and if secret hunting can slightly be easy to lose orientation. Still awesome and I liked the soundtrack to this.
nickster - One of the few maps that said no to the workhorse that is the pistol. The middle to end part of this map rock. Visually great as was expected. Really impressive. One of the best.
MonkeyShock - Cute and bitesized, a unique theme.
Bonn - Neat spin on Doom 2's start, the fact it was so similar and also not at the same time kept the surprises feel big.
Wons - Really well done atmosphere, gameplay is a little too oppressive early on but nothing too outrageous.
DraQu - Purple honey with meat! Love this visually, dense with a low secret count. The early combat is a little much at times, but I somehow liked the craziness when you get all the way down. Navigating for potential loot and optional zones can be a bit of a chore but still neat. One of the best.
PLaw - Some of the best combat and progression flow. Zones look great too. The ending is awesome and it keeps you on your toes. One of the best.
Colossus - Love the scale and look of each zone. Cosy combat with much to explore. The slaughter works great with qbj3's weapons. One of the best.
Mazu - It's a whole game in a map. Super dense, super tricky, every bit of the world feels intentionally placed. Story telling, puzzles, player agency. It's great. Imsim but with good combat. The void feels a little RNG but still fun to conquer. One of the best.
New Faces
efant - Cool freeform bitesized brutalist void that doubles up as a bmx park. On nightmare at times it's a bit much but it's good.
cYn - Bitesized with a great theme and story telling. Very good.
rudi - Weird eerie feel for the environments but the progression and combat were solid. We rise.
CKDN - Probably my favourite from this category. There are so many small details and sequences. Good flow and looks. One of the best.
Clenow - Amazing environments. Progression and combat were unique too. Great place to Do Crime in. Felt very dense, some of these secrets are incredibly hidden to me. One of the best.
ic - Cosy brutalism, scale is probably a tad too big but it was fun.
Softi - Can feel repetitive in nature but the combat waves were nice to go through. Nice aesthetic.
MrZuerg - A very belivable environment, nice to go through with neat combat.
Quiet - Yay for another stinky brutalist vibe. Short and to the point. I love the circular ladder. Nice aesthetics and secrets.
Kuroji - The big scale somehow meshed well with me but it definitely could be toned down. This is very clean and fun to go through.
racenis - And now this one could be scaled up lol. It is a little silly but still fun.
chaosed0 - Nice focused slaughter. Aesthetically cool too. One of the best.
tango - Bitesized fun.
maese47 - I assume there was supposed to be at least another room to this map as the ending / progression felt abrupt. Aesthetically this is nice, and up until the zombies combat is OK too.
Eldrydge - Nice lighting and accents, neat shapes too. Potentially could be scaled down but still fun.
ENEMY - Visually good most of the time, especially indoors. While open maps can be good this one kind of lacks an objective and some of the progression is sort of something you "stumble" into. Combat is nice.
Resurfaced
QBJ1 and 2 were a while ago, and while I remembered most of these maps, I actually had to go back and replay their old counter parts to appreciate some of the smaller details. Needless to say these Resurfaced versions play really well! I appreciate the encounter and balancing changes these received, and some even got some new lighting passes, especially noticeable in Spootnik's (great new final arena) and Strideh's (and sze's vegetation!). rabbit's map also is so fun with the wrench and pistol. My favourite though is also an old favourite with joymodulo's, which as far as I can tell received 2 quite big changes in the shape of secrets. Don't want to spoil too much but they are worth seeking out. I think combat wise the biggest difference (though I can't exactly tell as I didn't fully replay them as they are big, the other maps are shorter to compare) were in Mazu's and DraQu's. I never even completed Mazu's QBJ1 map, and the QBJ2 ending felt a lot more manageable with this arsenal. Likewise I don't know if I'm simply misremembering DraQu's being harder up until the end, as this version's ending still is tricky but nice to overcome. Progression is still a little weird but definitely doable with a bit of patience. Colossus' map with the MMML is awesome, and grue's mini "choose your own encounter" with the new powerups works great. Nickster's map with the MMML you have to really be careful with at the end but still rocks. Nail maze in bmFbr feels slightly touched but it could be the new model, pistolling here is so much nicer, the absence of the super nail gun for the end is felt though.
this is not a "product." it's art. we are not selling it. it's free. you do not have to play it, and we are not concerned with customer satisfaction. mapping jams are a celebration of the creativity of the community, not something to be sold.
btw Rover is canonically a lesbian, and so is the person that voices her in real life. enjoy that little factoid.